Dumb Local TV News
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
A friend who works in the news department of a local TV station sent me an e-mail recently. In it he lists down some of the reasons why, he believes, local TV news is not the best source of information.
Here's what he wrote:
Read more...
Local TV news is set up to be stupid. Allow me to enumerate the reasons:
1. Reports are generally limited to a running time of 1 minute 30 seconds. You can cram only so much information in that amount of time. This is a big limitation especially if you wish to do a really in-depth story on an issue that has a lot of data.
2. In general, people who apply for TV news on-cam work do so not because they want to be serious journalists. They just want to see their faces on TV and hopefully become famous. That is their main motivation.
3. Most people who apply for the position of TV reporter have mass comm or other related degrees. Writing and other "journalistic" skills are not at all honed in such courses given their generalized scope. It is also not unusual to see a newbie TV reporter being deployed to cover complicated senate sessions or court hearings.
4. Very little "writing" discipline is observed in TV news. Grammar even in Tagalog newscasts are practically ignored. This can be attributed to the fact that most script editors do not even bother to review the rules before they unleash their "editing" prowess on the reports submitted to them. This lack of "writing" discipline in the newsroom leads to the propagation of wrong writing rules invented by script editors who just want to appear they know what they are doing.
5. In TV news, soundbyte is king. This antiquated rule forces the whole TV news production team to use short, keyword-centric phrases from their interviews. Unfortunately, such phrases are more often than not just motherhood statements.
6. In TV news, premium is given to drama. In fact the writing structure used for TV news is called "dramatic unity" which basically means you have to start with the most dramatic part of the story. Again, unfortunately, more often than not the dramatic parts are not the most important or most substantial. Compare this to the print structure called the "inverted triangle" which says you start your story with the most important detail.
7. On cam people think popularity is credibility. It is not unusual to see airhead news anchors/readers/reporters being promoted as credible sources of information.
These are just a few of the things that doom TV news to be regarded as the stupidest source of information.


